Million Dollar YearGet the free app

Skool alternative: why I built my own coaching community platform

By Max Warnault · 1 April 2026 · 7 min read

In short

I left Skool because at scale it gives you one mixed feed, no AI, no automation, no customization, no upsell path and no ownership of your data. Moving to Circle, Mighty Networks or Kajabi only changes the landlord. I built my own platform with a feed for each tier, AI agents trained on my courses, a course system, an affiliate program and an in-platform upgrade path. People join free and upgrade without a sales call. That is product-led growth.

Right now almost every coaching community on the internet looks the same. Same layout, same single feed, same Skool branding. Mine looked like that too.

So I canceled my Skool subscription and built my own community platform. It has AI agents that answer questions 24/7, multiple community feeds, a course system, an affiliate program and a client acquisition funnel that runs itself. Here is why I did it, what was wrong at scale, and the framework that makes it work.

Why I was on Skool in the first place

Skool seemed like the obvious choice. Everyone was backing it and everyone was using it.

  • It cost $99 a month, which was affordable.
  • The setup was simple.
  • Engagement was decent compared to Facebook groups.
  • The gamification got people posting.

I was building a real community with paid members, and it was working. But the more I scaled, the more I hit a wall. It is like renting an apartment: you want to knock down a wall, and you can't, because it isn't yours.

The problems with Skool at scale

These are the problems that pushed me out:

  • One feed for everything. Free members, paid members, course questions and wins all land in the same place. At scale it is chaos, and important posts get buried.
  • The community turns into a support feed. Talking to a lot of people, I found many don't even log into Skool anymore, because it is always the same questions.
  • No AI and no automation. People ask the same question over and over, and you answer it by hand or pay someone to.
  • Zero customization. No custom domain, no custom colors, no custom fonts, so every community looks alike.
  • No client acquisition funnel. No upsell path and no automated progression from one level to the next.
  • Duct-taped tools. The only integration is Zapier, which I don't like, and I had canceled my Zapier subscription, so that was one more point of friction.
  • You own nothing. None of the data is yours.

I also noticed that the most successful Skool communities teach people how to make money on Skool. In practice they grow Skool for Skool.

Why Circle, Mighty Networks or Kajabi would not fix it

I could have moved to Circle, Mighty Networks or Kajabi. The problem would be the same: you are still renting your data. You get a different landlord on the same lease.

What I wanted was to own everything, because ownership is what makes product-led growth possible.

What product-led growth means for a coaching business

Product-led growth means people keep paying for the tool you built. Google Drive is the example. You sign up for free and get some storage. If you want to use it more, you pay.

In a coaching business, it works the same way. You get prospects for free, and they upgrade to your paid program on their own, without a sales call. The question I asked was: what if the platform itself converts free members to paid ones? That only works if you own the platform. You can't build product-led growth on Skool.

How my tiers work

Everything happens in one platform:

  1. Free: access to the community, the AI chatbot and some courses.
  2. Pro, at 100 a month in my case: the full courses, a deeper community, priority AI with fewer limits, and the ability to connect the AI to any tool you use.
  3. Inner Circle: live weekly coaching sessions, accountability and advanced systems.
  4. Done-for-you: my AI agency, where we build these systems for clients.

Six things my own platform does that Skool cannot

1. Multiple community feeds

Each tier has its own feed. There is a free community, a Pro community and an Inner Circle community, all separate. Posting works just like in Skool: videos or whatever you want.

2. AI chatbot agents

Members can chat with different agents: a general one, an offer advisor, a growth advisor and a cold email builder. I add more as I build new courses.

The agents can connect to the business tools people already use: Gmail, Google Calendar, Airtable, Notion, ActiveCampaign, GoHighLevel, Asana and others. This is agentic AI, meaning the AI takes actions in those tools on your behalf when you ask it to.

Because I own the platform, every new video I record is transcribed and added to the knowledge base. Every agent can answer questions from all my courses and training materials. The AI now does the technical support and answers most client questions.

3. A full course system

I'm recording a Claude Code Masterclass inside the platform right now. It shows how to set up Claude Code on your computer and connect it to every tool you use. Each time I record a video, I edit the lesson, add the video, and it is done. The lesson text was written with AI and sent in through API access, so all I have to do is record and go through the bullet points.

4. An affiliate program

Every member gets a referral link. They can bring people into the community or get them to upgrade to Pro or Inner Circle, and commissions are paid automatically. I built it with Stripe Connect. I manage it and all the data is mine. My affiliates get rewarded for bringing coaching clients to me.

5. Content ideas from community questions

AI monitors the questions members ask and surfaces content ideas in my admin section. Every question can become a YouTube video, an email or a course module. Your community tells you what to make content about. That only works because I own the data.

6. An automated client acquisition funnel

Everyone starts in the free community, upgrades to Pro, then to Inner Circle, and some become done-for-you agency clients. Each upgrade happens inside the platform, with no external sales page. I do have some paid pages that bring people straight in, but the free community is the main path. On Skool I had to DM and pitch people by hand. Here the free experience is good enough that upgrading is the obvious next step.

Putting the course, the agent and the community on one page

Where I'm taking this next is one page per lesson. You watch the lesson, an AI agent helps you do the task in it, and a community section lets you ask questions about that specific course. Each course has a specific task. We don't just teach people to think better, we help them take action. The goal is transformation.

What changed after I left Skool

  • Support: I used to spend about 10 hours a week on it. AI now handles about 80% of it, and I spend about 2 hours.
  • Client experience: adding AI to a Skool community meant juggling two platforms. Now clients get instant answers, the feeds are organized and everything is plugged in together.
  • Content: instead of guessing what to make, I pull from the community question feed.
  • Ownership: I control the domain, the branding and all the data. Every client and every question is in my own database.
  • Acquisition: the free tier converts to paid with no sales calls. My time is valuable, and people upgrade at their own pace.

I went from running a coaching business on a platform to running a coaching business that is the platform. At Million Dollar Year, this is what we mean by code as leverage: systems that keep working while you sleep.

Do you need to build your own platform?

I'm not telling you to build one from scratch. I'm telling you that you don't have to accept the limits of whatever platform you're on. You don't have to settle for one feed, zero AI and a page that looks like every other Skool page on the internet.

Key takeaways

  • Split your community into a separate feed for each tier so free members, paid members and course questions stop burying each other.
  • Train an AI agent on transcripts of every course video so it answers repeat questions instead of you.
  • Design a free tier good enough that upgrading feels obvious, so people move to paid without a sales call.
  • Keep every upgrade inside your platform, from free to paid to coaching to done-for-you.
  • Use the questions your members ask as your list of content ideas for videos, emails and course modules.
  • Own your platform and your data, because switching to another rented tool only changes the landlord.

Questions and answers

What are the problems with Skool for a growing coaching business?

At scale, Skool gives you one feed for everything, so important posts get buried and the community turns into a support channel. It has no AI or automation, no custom domain, colors or fonts, no upsell path, and the only integration is Zapier. You also don't own your data.

Is Circle, Mighty Networks or Kajabi a better Skool alternative?

In my view the core problem stays the same on those platforms: you are still renting your data. You get a different landlord on the same lease. I built my own platform so I could own everything.

What is product-led growth in a coaching business?

It means the product itself turns free users into paying ones, the way Google Drive gives you free storage and charges when you need more. In my coaching business, people join a free community with AI agents and some courses, then upgrade to paid tiers inside the platform without a sales call.

How can AI agents reduce support in a coaching community?

I transcribe every course video and add it to a knowledge base, so the agents can answer questions from all my training materials. AI now handles about 80% of support in my business. My own support time went from about 10 hours a week to about 2.

Do I need to build my own community platform from scratch?

No. My point is that you don't have to accept the limits of your current platform, like a single feed, no AI and the same look as every other community. What matters is owning your data and having an upgrade path that runs inside the platform.

For 6-figure coaches and agencies

Build a million dollar business, solo, with systems and AI.

Start with the free app: your year planned down to today, your numbers in one place, and exactly what your goal takes.

Get the free app

Free · No card · On the web and on your iPhone

Keep reading